Which Maca Is Best?
We offer several types of maca products made from different maca root colors and processing methods. If you’re wondering which maca is best for your needs, this guide will help you quickly match your goals with the right maca type and format.
Short Answer: Which Maca Is Best?
- Red maca — generally best for women (fertility, libido, menopause, bones, mood, skin).
- Black maca — generally best for men (fertility, libido, stamina, muscle strength, mental focus).
- Yellow or tri-color maca — excellent daily, budget-friendly choices for overall vitality.
- Raw maca — best for normal digestion.
- Gelatinized maca or extracts — best for sensitive digestion.
Take the Maca Finder quiz or explore the detailed information below to learn which maca is best for your age, activity level, lifestyle, and overall wellness goals.
If you have any questions please let us know. We're happy to help.
Jump to:
➤ How To Choose Maca in 3 Steps
➤ Differences Between Red, Black, Yellow & Tri-Color
➤ Raw vs. Gelatinized Maca
➤ What Is Premium Maca?
➤ Powders, Capsules, Chips, Extracts & Blends
➤ Best Maca for Women
➤ Best Maca for Men
➤ Best Maca for Shared Goals
➤ Maca Sampler Packs
How to Choose the Right Maca in 3 Simple Steps
- Identify your main goal(s): fertility, libido, energy, mood, menopause, strength, focus, skin, etc.
- Choose your maca color:
– Red maca: women’s health, mood, bones, skin.
– Black maca: men’s health, fertility, stamina, strength, mental focus.
– Yellow / tri-color maca: everyday energy and balance on a budget. - Match your digestion:
– Raw maca if you have normal digestion.
– Gelatinized or extracts if you have a sensitive stomach.
What Are the Differences Between Maca Colors?
Maca roots grow in 3 main color groups: black, red and yellow. Our products include all three plus a tri-color blend. While all maca is similar nutritionally, research and traditional use show some consistent traits:
- Red maca: women’s health, libido, menopause, bone density, mood support, skin.
- Black maca: men’s fertility, libido, stamina, muscle building, mental focus.
- Yellow maca: the traditional “everyday maca” for general vitality.
- Tri-color maca: a balanced daily blend of red, black and yellow roots.
Raw and Gelatinized Maca – Which Is Better?
Raw maca is low-temperature processed (never heated above ~100°F/40°C), preserving enzymes and nutrients at maximum levels. It’s the best choice for people with normal to strong digestion and for those who want the full nutritional profile.
Gelatinized maca is gently heated to remove starch. This process destroys enzymes and vitamin C, but leaves major nutrients intact. Gelatinized maca is easier to digest, slightly more concentrated, and ideal for anyone with digestive sensitivity or who is new to maca.
What Is Premium Maca?
Premium maca is made by drying the roots in low-temperature dehydrators immediately after harvest. This preserves higher levels of glucosinolates—nutrients studied for hormone and cellular support. If you are taking maca for maximum glucosinolates and have a strong palate they will be a good choice for you.
- More potent; stronger taste
- Lighter color and finer texture
- Best if you already know your body responds well to maca
Which Maca Format Should I Choose?
| Format | Advantages | Disadvantages |
|---|---|---|
| Maca Powder | Most economical; easy to mix into smoothies and recipes; full flavor and flexibility. | Some people don’t like the taste; requires preparation. |
| Maca Capsules | Taste-free; convenient; precise dosing; portable. | More expensive per serving; slower absorption than powder/extract. |
| Maca Extracts | Fast absorption; gentle on digestion; alcohol-free; great taste; very portable. | Less traditional; pricing is higher per serving. |
| Maca Chips | Closest to whole maca root; great for teas and traditional recipes; long-lasting. | Not ideal for quick daily dosing; requires simmering or steeping. |
| Maca Blends | Best flavor; combines maca with synergistic superfoods; great for smoothies. | Less concentrated maca per serving; may not suit purists. |
All of our maca is grown in a remote, pristine region of the Peruvian Andes — GMO-free, certified organic, sustainably cultivated, and purchased at fair-trade prices. All of our maca products are tested and results are availble on each individual product page.
Best Maca for Women
Below are the most common women’s health goals and the maca types we recommend based on over 2 decades of experience and research.
Female Fertility
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Premium Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
Red maca supports hormone balance, cycles and reproductive vitality.
Female Libido
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Premium Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
Traditionally used to support libido and healthy circulation.
Menopause
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Premium Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
May support mood, energy, hot flashes and overall hormone balance.
Osteoporosis & Bone Support
Top types: Red or Black Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Black Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Black Maca
Red maca has shown strong results in early bone-density research.
Hair Health
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Premium Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
Supports healthier, fuller hair through nutrient and hormone balance.
Acne / Skin Balance
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Premium Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
Often chosen for hormone-related skin concerns.
Best Maca for Men
These maca recommendations are based on traditional use, customer experience and early scientific findings regarding men’s vitality.
Male Fertility
Top type: Black Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Black Maca
Premium Raw Black Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Black Maca
Gelatinized Premium Black Maca
Black maca is the most researched maca for male reproductive health.
Male Libido
Top type: Black Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Black Maca
Premium Raw Black Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Black Maca
Gelatinized Premium Black Maca
Traditionally used to support male libido and vitality.
ED Support
Top type: Black Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Black Maca
Raw Premium Black Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Black Maca
Gelatinized Premium Black Maca
Supports stamina, circulation and consistent energy.
Prostate Health
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Premium Raw Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
Red maca has been associated with prostate volume support in preliminary studies.
Muscle Building
Top type: Black Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Black Maca
Premium Raw Black Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Black Maca
Gelatinized Premium Black Maca
Black maca is the top choice for performance and lean muscle support.
Stamina & Endurance
Top type: Black Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Black Maca
Premium Raw Black Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Black Maca
Gelatinized Premium Black Maca
Excellent for athletes, labor-intensive work and overall vitality.
Best Maca for Shared Goals (Women & Men)
These maca recommendations apply equally to women and men.
Energy
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Premium Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
Red maca provides clean, consistent daytime energy.
Mental Focus
Top types: Red or Black Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Black Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Black Maca
Black maca may offer the strongest mental-performance effects.
Low Mood / Depression
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Premium Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
Red maca is traditionally associated with emotional balance and mood elevation.
Chronic Fatigue
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Premium Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
Provides steady, adaptogenic energy support.
Anxiety / Stress
Top types: Red or Black Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Black Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Black Maca
Red maca calms while black maca helps with stress resilience.
Circulation
Top type: Red Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Premium Red Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Premium Red Maca
Traditionally used to support blood flow and oxygenation.
Blood Pressure (Women & Men)
Top types: Red or Black Maca
Normal digestion:
Raw Red Maca
Raw Black Maca
Sensitive digestion:
Gelatinized Red Maca
Gelatinized Black Maca
**These statements and recommendations come from our 20+ years of experience and research with maca. They have not been approved by the FDA and are not meant to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. If you have health concerns, please contact a qualified medical professional. Full disclaimer here.
Still Not Sure Which Maca to Choose?
Our Maca Sampler Packs allow you to try a variety of maca colors and processing types at discounted prices. Click here for details.
If you still have questions, we’re here to help. Contact us any time.
Enjoy your day!
